One of the narratives of the November test matches that may have been lost in some of the controversy that has followed the fifth round of the Nations Championship is the decisive role that scrumhalves have played in many of the games.
The big talking point games last weekend were the wins for France against the Springboks in Paris and the seismic upset in Cardiff where Wales beat New Zealand for the first time since 1953. In both those clashes scrumhalves played pivotal roles for their team, while the players in opposition were a bit off their game and their teams paid for it.
Of course, in the Stade de France game, won 21-19 by the home team, it is hard to pinpoint which of Maxime Lucu or Antoine Dupont was actually the scrumhalf. Dupont wore the No 10 on his back, but he and Lucu swopped roles and dovetailed superbly.
The Bok scrumhalf Morne van den Berg, the man of the match when the South Africans buried Italy in Turin in their opening tour match with an impressive and decisive first-half performance, did not back up that performance.
And while the Welsh were brilliant in the way they attacked the breakdown against the All Blacks, and James Botham was man of the match and could easily have been joined in getting that award by his fellow loose-forwards, it was really Tomos Williams who was the home team’s stand-out performer in Wales’ 35-28 win at the Principality Stadium.
It wasn’t necessarily his fault, because he got held up by lack of protection from his forwards, but New Zealand’s Cortez Ratimer was a distant second in the battle of the No 9s in that game and that contributed to the result.
Cam Roigard will no doubt return and together with Damian McKenzie, who didn’t play last week, they should pose a very different threat to England at halfback than the one that was posed in Cardiff, where Richie Mo’unga’s rustiness was exposed in the All Black No 10 jersey.
The narrative has been set though, and Saturday’s decisive games in both the southern hemisphere and northern hemisphere logs could come down to scrumhalf excellence. Van den Berg has been backed by Bok coach Rassie Erasmus and will continue in the No 9 jersey in Dublin, where the world champions face Ireland.
The change at scrumhalf for the Boks hasn’t come in the starting team, but on the bench, where Cobus Reinach drops out to accommodate the return of the less experienced but younger Grant Williams.
Together those two halfbacks will be tasked with matching another of the world’s best scrumhalves in Jamison Gibson-Park, who has had some hugely influential games both for both Ireland and the British and Irish Lions in recent years.
Sam Prendergast has rather bizarrely, and as predicted by Erasmus in his ill-fated team announcement press conference on Monday, been cleared of wrong-doing and is likely to line up against the Boks at flyhalf.
That isn’t something that will have the South Africans quaking in their boots and Erasmus’ stated concern over the World Rugby judicial process wouldn’t have been driven by any fear of a threat that Prendergast can bring. He is a decidedly average though over-hyped player who should be at the AVIVA Stadium to ask for Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu’s autograph rather than to line up against him.
You wouldn’t say the same about Gibson-Park, with so much of the Ireland game revolving around him, as noted by Williams.
“He’s up there with Dupont,” said the Bok. “He is a brilliant player and he is probably the key to how Ireland play. It will be a massive challenge for myself and Morne this weekend.”
Should Williams contribute well off the Bok bench and prove decisive in a Bok win, the Irish will end up blaming two of their own for that, as Williams credits the two Irishmen on the Bok coaching staff, Felix Jones and Jerry Flannery, with being big influences on his game.
“First of all, they bring a different energy. I came through into the Bok setup when Felix was the attack coach so he has had a lot of influence on how I play. And then later Jerry joined and like I said, it was just a different energy. I think it’s refreshing to all of us.”

